Movie Review: The Odyssey (no plot spoilers)

The Odyssey movie poster. Image: IMDB
MOVIE REVIEW: THE ODYSSEY (NO PLOT SPOILERS)
I walked out of the theater after seeing The Odyssey with these thoughts and feelings:
“Spectacular, awesome, massive, intense, harrowing, violent, merciful, evocative, fearful, seductive, humbling, restrained, overwhelming, noble, epic… an immersive experience, not just a movie.”
I found the film noble, uplifting, and immensely satisfying. For those who haven’t read the story that was written 2,800 years ago, I won’t spoil the ending.
The Film

The Odyssey theater display. Author’s photo
I saw the film in 70mm IMAX, and it was stunning. It filled the entire screen from floor to ceiling.
Over the course of its opening weekend, The Odyssey grossed a colossal $264.1 million worldwide (more than its original production cost), giving Nolan his biggest-ever global opening. In the US alone, it raked in $124.5M, almost half of the worldwide total. In its second week, it made an additional $87M in the U.S. With international grosses, some outlets report the film has earned $650M worldwide. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film has a 94% positive critics’ score and a 97% audience score.
The story picks up after the Trojan War (told in The Iliad, also by the Greek poet Homer), though there are frequent flashbacks to the war. Most of the characters you’d expect are in this film: the Cyclops Polyphemus, portrayed as you’ve never seen him before, the dangerous Sirens, the sorceress Circe (Samantha Morton), and the nymph Calypso (Charlize Theron).
The Cast
Matt Damon as Odysseus

Matt Damon. Image: IMDB
Matt Damon is the everyman of modern films. He’s accessible, relatable, and transparent in his acting. You’ve seen him in comedies, thrillers, dramas, and action movies like the Jason Bourne films. This is one of his most compelling and mesmerizing performances.
Tom Holland as Telemachus

Tom Holland. Image: IMDB
There is a historical St. Telemachus I’ve written about previously. This isn’t him. Here, Telemachus is the son of Odysseus and his wife Penelope. The youth hasn’t seen his father in 20 years and seeks him. Holland, who is better known for his portrayal of Spider-Man, is well cast here in this coming-of-age role, more than a boy, less than the man who might replace his father as King of Ithaca.
It should be noted, because even NPR recently got this wrong, that Odysseus spends 10 years at sea (The Odyssey) endeavoring to return home from the Trojan War, but the war itself (The Iliad) lasted 10 years.
Telemachus is tutored, advised, and protected by Mentor, his father’s trusted friend. That’s where we get the word.
Telemachus is Greek for “far from battle” or “fighting from afar.”
Anne Hathaway as Penelope

Anne Hathaway. Image: IMDB
Anne Hathaway is a favorite of writer/director/producer Christopher Nolan and previously appeared in his Batman film The Dark Knight Rises and his science fiction film Interstellar.
Penelope is the cousin of Helen, wife of the Spartan king Menelaus, who eloped with, or was abducted by, Paris of Troy, fomenting the Trojan War (which launched a thousand ships) as her abandoned husband sought her return.
Hathaway as Penelope is the faithful wife who has waited 20 years for her husband Odysseus to return; she’s beautiful, brittle, and angry.
Robert Pattinson as Antinous

Robert Pattinson. Image: IMDB
Among the many suitors of Penelope, Antinous is the most arrogant and most despicable. Pattinson was previously in Nolan’s Tenet film. In this movie, as the lead suitor, he plays the role so creepily that it drives out memories of the attractive boy Cedric in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Edward in The Twilight Saga, or even the dark-night detective in The Batman.

Agamemnon. Image: IMDB
Trivia: The faceless character Agamemnon resembles Batman with a helmet that covers the top of his face, blackened bronze armor, and a long black cape.
Entertainment vs. History
I’m not writing this review as a historian, but more as a classicist, a major I enjoyed for a few months, and as a student of ancient Greek for a year and a half while at university.
A reader asked me if the film was historically accurate. That is difficult to answer because the story of The Odyssey contains both mythological elements, such as monsters and Greek gods, and historical elements and actual geographical locations. For example, we’ve had evidence since 1870 from excavations of Hisarlik in Turkey that it is the probable location of ancient Troy.

Journey of Odysseus
It may be better to ask if the film is faithful to the epic poem The Odyssey. The short answer is… not exactly.
There are plenty of current articles criticizing the film for its historical inaccuracies, from armor to casting. One of the most scathing reviews is by Emily Wilson, the classicist whose 2017 English translation of The Odyssey not only increased interest in the epic, but was the text that Christopher Nolan used for the film. But she was encouraged that the film has increased readership of the epic and study of the classics.

The Odyssey, translated by Emily Wilson. Image: Amazon
Almost any retelling of the story, especially on film, is going to have to make different compromises.
It is accurate to say that this film is a modern retelling of the ancient legend seen through 21st-century postmodern eyes. It inverts some of the heroic tropes and makes Odysseus a more sympathetic man rather than a heroic and resourceful warrior.
Christopher Nolan presents us with a modern, accessible, relevant man. This Odysseus is more approachable, with a powerful sense of guilt and trauma rather than the Bronze Age’s cunning killer-king seeking victory and glory.
One Final Ancient Greek Note

Rhapsode by Giandomenico Tiepolo. Image: Wikipedia
Tradition holds that The Odyssey was composed as a poem from oral tradition by Homer around the 8th or 7th century B.C.
It was subsequently recited as part of the Greek literary canon in public performances by a rhapsode, or “singer of stitched lays.” This is where we get the word “rhapsody.”
Grade: B+
You’ll like it if: you enjoy large action set pieces or expensive sword-and-sandal films.
You won’t like it if: fidelity to the original story is important to you or you were expecting a non-musical version of O Brother, Where Art Thou?
Bill Petro, your friendly neighborhood historian
billpetro.com